18

Welcome to Wealth Informatics! If this is your first time visiting the site, please start here.

Why you should not use your 401k

Max out your 401k… It is one of the most commonly given pieces of advice by many financial experts. With the 2011 401k contribution limit of $16,500, it IS one of the best ways to save a good chunk of money for your golden days. But not everyone should use their 401k to save for their retirement. For some people the company sponsored 401k might be a very bad deal. Why should you not use your 401k? Because of the 401k fees. Oh I am using a cheap index fund, so I am good… you might think. Well the fund’s expense ratio is only part of your 401k fees, in some cases the expense ratio might be dwarfed by other hidden 401k fees. Do you know all your 401k fees? According to a recent survey by AARP, 71% of the 401k participants surveyed said they do not pay any fees, which is not possible. And 62% said they have no idea how much they are paying in 401k fees.

401k fees survey

First of all if your employer is matching your contribution, def. contribute at least up to that matching amount to take full advantage of the free money. But beyond that, evaluate whether your own traditional/ROTH IRA is a better deal than a company sponsored 401k. It might be.

Quick rundown on how 401k works

  • 401k is sponsored by your employer (who is called the “plan sponsor”)
  • You can choose to contribute as much or as little you want (within the 401k contribution limit set by the government)
  • Employer might choose to match your contribution up to a certain amount (Example : 100% match up to 6% of your salary)
  • If it is a traditional 401k, the entire contribution is tax deductible, if it is a ROTH 401k you can’t deduct the amount, but you can withdraw the amount tax free during retirement.
  • The employer will select a brokerage/company to manage your 401k, they are the service providers.
  • Based on the negotiation between your company and the brokerage, you will get a certain set of investments to choose from.
  • The company will also negotiate the fees for other services with the brokerage.

Overall, 401k is a great retirement vehicle, but it is only as good as what your company negotiated for you. The last 2 points (investment choices and fees) could be a real deal breaker and cost you a boat load of money. So what are these 401k fees I am talking about? The fees can be roughly categorized into 3 buckets – Asset based, Plan administration & Transaction and service based fee.

401k fees – Asset based

Asset based fees are taken out of your assets, so you will never see this in your account statement. For example, if the asset based fees totals to 1% and you have $10,000 in your 401k, every year you are paying $100 to keep that $10,000 invested. This category includes – Management, expense ratio and investment advice .

  • Management fees : If all your funds are managed, meaning it has an investment manager who actively makes decisions on what the fund will hold, then you will be paying a management fee.
  • Expense ratio : This is the most widely known fee. This is based on the fund you choose. This is the total of the mutual fund’s operating expenses paid by the fund.
  • Investment advice : Some companies have an external firm advising the employer on their investment selection. For example, some companies may choose a firm like Financial Engines to help with their employee’s retirement plans. And Financial Engines will take a % of your assets. This is in addition to the expense ratio of the fund they will invest your money in.

Example :
$10000 invested in Fund A with 0.2% expense ratio = 10000*0.002 = $20
$10000 invested in Fund A with 0.8% expense ratio = 10000*0.008 = $80
$100 fee deducted from the assets every year.

Who pays them? You. As I said, this is deducted from your assets so you won’t see it in the statement.

How to reduce them : Choose a good low cost index fund. If your company’s 401k plan has limited choice of funds, all of them with high costs, contribute just enough to get the company match and invest the rest (up to $5000) in an IRA. Based on the company you choose, you will have an excellent selection of low cost mutual funds without any additional choices. And make sure to roll over your costly 401k to your IRA when you change companies.

401k fees : Plan administration

This is the second category of fees that is charged for the administration of the workplace retirement plan. This is not a flat fee for all the companies, it is negotiated by your company. Generally smaller sized companies have higher plan administration fees due to their lower bargaining  power in negotiations.

  • Record keeping & accounting : This might include monitoring employee deferrals, employer matching, profit sharing contributions, vesting schedule, conducting legally required audits and reports to the DOL.
  • Custody and trustee service : A custodian, a trust company physically holds the plan assets.
  • Other admin fees : Any other admin services like educational seminars, dedicated customer service lines, access to retirement planning software, electronic access to plan information, etc.

Example : $10 plan administrator fee per quarter X 4 (number of quarters per year) = $40 annual maintenance fee.

Who pays them? In some cases the employers pay them, some companies happily pass all the expenses to you. The amount you pay is negotiated by employers. These will be deducted mostly quarterly and you will see them in the statements.

How to reduce them : The only way to reduce this part of the fees is to talk to your employer. Some times in small companies it might be the lack of people to research the expenses better, if you talk to your HR and form a 401k committee within your company by taking volunteers, you can research the fees, talk to different brokerages and submit recommendations. As long as it won’t cost your company a lot of money most companies will listen to your concerns, esp. if you are willing to do most of the work.

401k fees : Transaction and service based fee

This fees is for any special transaction or service you might use. For example 401k loan fees, or for doing all the legal paperwork in your divorce to split the assets or termination fees if your company wants to change service providers.

Example : If you take a 401k loan, other than the interest rate,
$125 loan initiation fee (one time fee)
$5 ongoing maintenance fee per quarter X 4 (number of quarters per year) = $20 annual maintenance fee.
$145 for the first year and $20 every year.

Who pays them? Mostly you, in some cases, the employer. The amount is also negotiated by the employers.

Why should I care about these 401k fees?

The percentage esp. without doing the actual calculation might seem small, but with the power of compound interest, it will eat into a big chunk of your retirement fund. To illustrate, lets take an hypothetical example. Lets say you have $100000 in assets right now (for the sake of simplicity I have ignored the extra yearly contribution).

You work in a company A which has the following fees
Total assets  : $100000
Fund A : expense ratio = 0.69%
Total Asset based fee = $690
Other admin fee =$100 (0.1%)
Total fees : $690+$100/$100000 = 0.79%

Your friend works for company B which has a better fund selection
Total assets  : $100000
Fund A : expense ratio = 0.19%
Total Asset based fee = $190
Other admin fee = $0
Total fees : $190+$0/$100000 = 0.19%

 

401 k fees over the years

Growth of the 2 funds over the years

401k fees comparison

You end up with $226k, your friend will end up with $255k, just due to the difference in expenses

Both of you had the same amount to start with and invested for lets say 20 yrs. He will have ~$29000 more than you do. Add in regular yearly contributions and if you have a large enough asset, the difference could be close to $500,000. That’s a pretty big chunk of change, don’t you think?

When to use 401k?
If the overall fees is low for your company (call you HR and the plan administrator to clearly get an itemized fee list), contribute the max by all means.

When not to use 401k?
You should use your 401k to take full advantage of the company match. Beyond that if you are planning to invest <=$5000 (if you are <50 yrs old, $6000 if you are 50+), open an IRA with Vanguard or Fidelity or any low cost brokerage firm like Scottrade, Optionshouse etc. Some companies will have a fee if you have low balance, it might be waived for an IRA with regular contribution, check that out. That way the only fee you will pay is the expense ratio.

401k fee disclosure in 2012

The Department of Labor Employee Benefits Security Administration came up with a rule that requires all the 401k plan providers to clearly spell out the fees and expenses each quarter, starting in Jan 2012. It is a great step in the right direction, but it will only be as useful as the effort we put in too. How many people actually open and read the fund prospectus that these companies actually send out? How many people take serious effort to regularly check if their funds are still the best in class? Investing in an index fund is better than chasing hot stocks any day. But “too” much of passive investing is not a great idea either. After all, we are the only ones responsible for our future right? The bottom line : if you don’t know exactly how much your 401k in costing you, give your HR and your plan company a call.

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Steve

Even the HR department may not know what fees are in there. That’s perhaps part of the problem – they are not accountants and don’t really understand the contracts they are negotiating. More than once I have had to figure it out myself.

Usually I figure it out by comparing the expense ratio of the wrap account, listed in the 401(k) documentation, to the expense ratio of the underlying mutual fund as listed in the prospectus. E.g. “Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Account” might be listed with an 0.83% expense ratio in the employee handout. I look up the expense ratio for VTSMX and find it is 0.18%. Therefore the fees are 0.65%. Usually I have found the difference to be consistent across all the fund options (though the time there were 50+ options, I only checked a sampling.)

Reply

Financial Samurai

To be frank, I kinda just hope my company isn’t doing the right thing and isn’t gouging us. Max it out, invest wisely, and let it snowball!

Sam

Reply

Suba

Sam, just trusting your employer to do the right thing is a bad idea :)

Reply

Miss T @ Prairie Eco-Thrifter

We don’t have a 401 K in Canada but we do have RRSP’s and pension plans. I think they have their place and are great as part of a strategy but they shouldn’t be your whole strategy.

Reply

Suba

Agreed, Miss T.

Reply

Super Frugalette

I think although a 401K is not perfect if the options are either 1) stick money in a 401k or 2) spend it…people should always go for #1.

Reply

Suba

Absolutely right, Super Frugalette. And as I mentioned, it is ALWAYS good to contribute to 401k to get the employer match. I was mainly talking about the excess contribution. If I can contribute $8000 and my employer matched only $4000, I would contribute $4000 to 401k to get the contribution and the rest of the $4000 in an IRA (if my 401k has all these fees, that is).

Reply

Steve

You also have to consider how long you plan at working in the same place. I’ve never worked the same place longer than 4 years (and most jobs, less than that), nowhere near long enough to amass $100k in a single 401(k). As soon as I leave a job, I roll it over.

In fact, I think there is a correlation between how bad a 401(k) is and the average employee tenure being short. One of the reasons for a bad 401k is an employer who doesn’t care much about their employees.

Reply

Robert @ The College Investor

You should also think about not doing it if your employer doesn’t offer a match. If they do, the fees may not be that bad because you get essentially free money. No match, and killer fees? Bad 401k.

Reply

Bret @ Hope to Prosper

We have the Principal at work and I’m pretty sure their fees are high. Even worse, they have their own tracking funds, instead of investing the the real mutual funds they track. This probably allows them to capture mangement fees on top of the sales fees. Even more worse, we don’t get any matching.

Despite all of this, I contribute a substantial amount into my 401K each paycheck. Like all of my previous 401Ks, I will roll it into my self-directed IRA if I leave the company. And, the performance has been pretty good so far. It’s far better to save in a plan with high fees, than to never save at all.

I honestly believe most people wouldn’t save for retirement at all, if it wasn’t for their company’s 401K plan. I just wish the government would limit the fees for qualified plans.

Reply

First Gen American

My 401K hasn’t been a crappy investment for me. The first 11 years of my career, I could only invest in my company stock or my company’s mutual fund. That ended up being a disaster for my savings when the 2008 crash happened. I still max out the pretax minimum but I won’t do any after tax contributions anymore. I’m going to manage the rest my way. Live and Learn

Reply

Dividend Monk

My employer offers only index funds, which is essentially the best thing they could offer. Expenses are low, and with proper asset allocation, it’s a very wise investing strategy.

Still, I only contribute enough to receive full matching. After that, I have other uses for my money. In consequence, my 401(k) represents only a small fraction of my accumulation.

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 6 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: